The last couple weeks have been all about climate change. There were
the
hacked emails from scientists and the controversy that ensued. Then
there is the
climate conference in Copenhagen, which gives me hope that
the US would finally stop waffling and do something.
And the
there were the
big snowstorms and
freezing temperatures in the American
Midwest that made us Minnesotans wish that warmer temperatures were the
only consequence of global warming. ('Cause seriously, when the
weather is -8°F/-13°C, going outside is pretty darn awful!)
So since climate change is what we're all talking about, I feel that it's time I chime in with what I believe with all my heart: I
have absolutely no interest in getting into the argument about whether
climate change is occurring or not. Why? Because it goes nowhere. In
America, people stick to their beliefs like they're two opposing armies
on a battlefield who have build their fortifications and won't stop
until the other side is completely vanquished.
All arguing does is
cause the other side to reinforce their beliefs.I do have a
very strong opinion on this issue though.
I think climate change
legislation is a great idea. But probably not for the reasons you
expect.
First of all, I think that it is awful that
companies are blithely spewing noxious chemicals into the air and into
the earth. And they are - you won't find anyone who doesn't believe
that.
More importantly though. I think climate change legislation is an absolute must if we Americans want to continue being known for our innovative spirit!
Whether or not you agree that climate change is occurring, it's a fact that a large majority of the world does - and is enacting legislation to
combat it. This is something we cannot ignore as innovators!
If
we ignore climate change in the US, we risk becoming
obsolete as exporters as the rest of the world restricts technology
that emits large amounts of CO2. And we risk becoming obsolete within
our own country as well, as foreign companies make breakthroughs.
The fact is, companies don't
make drastic innovation breakthroughs without a good reason. If they
can continue spewing chemical into the air without punishment, they
will. Why do you think that our cars get
barely more miles per gallon (MPG) now than they
did in the 1970s?
Detroit has stubbornly refused
(
not "failed".. "refused") to innovate significantly in the past
20-30 years.
From
Detroit's side, SUV's and trucks are a cash cow. They cost nominally
more to make than cars, and bring in oodles of money. So, as long as
Detroit could convince Americans that they need that giant truck, their
business model was golden and they had no incentive to look ahead. And
then they over-committed themselves to inflexible factories and when
the market shifted, they went down in flames. (As they should have.)
As for the argument about letting the
markets choose, that's a horribly bad idea if we want America to be an innovative leader in the future.
There's an interesting correspondence between cost of
new green technology and energy prices. When gas is expensive, that
pricey Prius looks pretty good (and thus the price drops for future
high mph vehicles as supply rises and the supply chain is optimized for
higher volume). And in that case, the free market is a beautiful thing.
But when gas is artificially cheap, people are very susceptible
to the intense marketing campaigns that Detroit runs to convince
Americans that a big truck is one of their fundamental rights. I'd like
to think the masses were more forward-thinking and less susceptible to emotional manipulation than that, but
they usually aren't. (For
proof, I offer up the slimy DeBeers
diamond engagement ring campaign that began in 1938 and convinced Americans that only a
diamond can prove someone loves you. Masterful marketing campaign...
but very manipulative. And trust me, if a guy ever tries to tell his
future fiance about
how she's been manipulated to want a diamond... he'll be in the
doghouse for months. The marketing was THAT good.)
So whenever
companies can convince consumers that they should remain stuck in the
past and resist innovation - they usually do. Many will throw
everything they have into resisting the need to innovate. (Yes music industry, I'm talking about you.)For many companies, their most important goal is to make their quarterly books look as good as possible
for the shareholders. As a result, they have no incentive to look ahead and prepare
for the future. Their incentive is to sell what's profitable now. Chances are, the CEO who is raking in oodles of money
won't even be around when the market turns. So, too many companies
operate in the here and now.
But
when companies finally know they need to change (or risk huge fines or market
losses), they do so incredibly well. American companies especially. We
have such innovative capacity here in the US that we could lead the
world in environmental innovation.
Instead though, we bicker constantly about whether climate change is actually occurring. We
stall, and waffle, and do everything we can to avoid making a
short-term painful decision that will pay off for us in the long run.
Right now, in the climate change debate, we're just being dragged along
by the rest of the world like a reluctant child who doesn't want to do its homework.
That's
not the America I believe in. I see America as a country that seizes
opportunities to be a world leader. This climate bickering is not
conducive to that - and it's not an issue that is going to go away. So
we need to get off our butts and start moving forward now.
Innovators
don't sit back and resist change. They seize it and use all their
brilliance to find out how to take advantage of every situation. We
need to do that.
It's
time for us to stop being the obstructionists
who are missing opportunities to really benefit from this situation.
It's time for America to sign the climate change agreement in
Copenhagen, stop bitching about it at home, and get our butts into our garages and labs to make some magic.
And I can't wait for the American government to step up, take a stance and pass legislation that actually makes us do it.
Recent Comments